Sunday, January 11, 2015

The Flaw in Picking the All-Star Teams

How does one decide who is worthy of playing in the NHL All-star game. Do you go by individual stats, popularity, or the strength of teams?





Popularity rules when it comes to picking the starting line-ups, as the starters are determined by fan votes. Largely, you see the same players year after year, such as Sidney Crosby or Patrick Kane. Occasionally, you will see a less popular player get voted in if they are having a stellar season








For the rest of the line-ups, GM's and other NHL executives pick the players. Of course, a big challenge is representing all 30 NHL teams. A lot of times, players that should make the team due to individual stats are left off the roster because of the need to pick players from other teams. For example, PK Subban was not picked for the 2015 all-star game. In my hometown of Vancouver, the Sedin Twins were left off the roster. Looking at this issue from a team performance standpoint, 1st place Montreal has only goalie Carey Price going to the all-star game. On the other hand, Columbus, currently in 12th place has three players playing in the all-star game. Yes, I recognize that Columbus is hosting the all-star game this year. However, that should not be reason enough to send three players to the all-star game. I think individual stats and position of team in the standings should carry more weight than merely hosting the game.

There is still a chance Subban could be added to the roster if a player (defenseman) pulls out of the game due to injury, personal reasons, or simply needing to recharge the batteries. Congratulations to Carey Price for making the all-star team. He is a great choice to represent the Habs based on another outstanding start to the season. Price has been the MVP of the team, allowing the Habs to win games they should have lost.

#GoHabsGo

A Habs Fan blogging from BC

3 comments:

Just like with baseball, i hate the whole each team must be represented rule. If a team sucks and they have no one worthy, they should not be represented. Lesser players shouldn't go because they are the best of the crap of that team. Sorry, Justin Faulk, Patrick Elias or Ryan Nugent-Hopkins. You're not worthy and your teams are garbage.

I remember not too long ago when the game was played in Montreal and Their fans stuffed the ballot boxes, so go cry froggie tears elsewhere. BTW Subban isnt worth close to $9 Mil

Hey guys, if you want check out my simple Montreal Canadiens app. It's beta and has some bugs but I'm working on it.

iOS - http://bit.ly/1uk3omi
Android - http://bit.ly/1J6McHF

. Shows you the time left for the next Montreal Canadiens game.

. Rings an alarm before the game begins.

. And also gives you news and live commentary.

Thanks, bye!

Post a Comment